Child sickened by raw milk; Marler sues
The North County Times reports that Tony Martin and his wife, Mary McGonigle-Martin, of Murrieta, California, have filed a civil lawsuit in Fresno County after their then seven-year-old son was sickened with E. coli O157:H7 and hospitalized for two months in 2006.
According to the lawsuit filed Feb. 6, Chris developed hemolytic uremic syndrome, a common cause of kidney failure, due to E. coli infection.
Hospitalized from Sept. 7 to Nov. 2, 2006, Chris "suffered life-threatening injuries that have left him permanently injured," the suit states. The Martins have incurred more than $450,000 in medical bills.
The suit says the source of the E. coli was raw milk produced at Organic Pastures Dairy in Fresno and sold by a Sprouts store in Temecula.
Sprouts store owner Linda Watson was quoted as saying,
"There is no information I know of that any E. coli in any raw milk was sold at our store, or anywhere else for that matter."
A table of raw-milk related outbreaks is available at http://www.foodsafety.ksu.edu/articles/384/RawMilkOutbreakTable.pdf
Mark McAfee, owner of Organic Pastures Dairy in Fresno, said there is no proof that his company is at fault, as also alleged in the lawsuit, adding,
"When a person sues for a food-related illness, they must be able to show a connection between a product and the person. There isn't a connection here. … Because there isn't any connection, we feel confident we have a very strong defense."
Seattle attorney Bill Marler who is representing the Martins in their lawsuit, said,
"Under California law, the whole distribution chain is strictly liable. We don't have to prove the store did anything wrong or was negligent, just that it was in the product. Selling unpasteurized milk is a risk stores shouldn't be willing to take. … The message here is, whether it is raw or pasteurized milk, you have to be willing to take the responsibility of making sure your product is safe for your consumers."
Tony Martin was further quoted as saying,
"We live in a society where people are not that concerned with getting a pathogen and they need to be," and that some proponents of raw milk are "zealots" in the ways they push the product.
According to the lawsuit filed Feb. 6, Chris developed hemolytic uremic syndrome, a common cause of kidney failure, due to E. coli infection.
Hospitalized from Sept. 7 to Nov. 2, 2006, Chris "suffered life-threatening injuries that have left him permanently injured," the suit states. The Martins have incurred more than $450,000 in medical bills.
The suit says the source of the E. coli was raw milk produced at Organic Pastures Dairy in Fresno and sold by a Sprouts store in Temecula.
Sprouts store owner Linda Watson was quoted as saying,
"There is no information I know of that any E. coli in any raw milk was sold at our store, or anywhere else for that matter."
A table of raw-milk related outbreaks is available at http://www.foodsafety.ksu.edu/articles/384/RawMilkOutbreakTable.pdf
Mark McAfee, owner of Organic Pastures Dairy in Fresno, said there is no proof that his company is at fault, as also alleged in the lawsuit, adding,
"When a person sues for a food-related illness, they must be able to show a connection between a product and the person. There isn't a connection here. … Because there isn't any connection, we feel confident we have a very strong defense."
Seattle attorney Bill Marler who is representing the Martins in their lawsuit, said,
"Under California law, the whole distribution chain is strictly liable. We don't have to prove the store did anything wrong or was negligent, just that it was in the product. Selling unpasteurized milk is a risk stores shouldn't be willing to take. … The message here is, whether it is raw or pasteurized milk, you have to be willing to take the responsibility of making sure your product is safe for your consumers."
Tony Martin was further quoted as saying,
"We live in a society where people are not that concerned with getting a pathogen and they need to be," and that some proponents of raw milk are "zealots" in the ways they push the product.
Trackbacks (0)
Links to blogs that reference this article
Trackback URL
http://barfblog.foodsafety.ksu.edu/admin/trackback/62734
http://barfblog.foodsafety.ksu.edu/admin/trackback/62734
Post A Comment / Question
Use this form to add a comment to this entry.
Send To A Friend
Use this form to send this entry to a friend via email.
The problem with this lawsuit is that there is ZERO evidence that the e coli originated at Organic Pastures. The entire food chains at Organic PAstures was tested, ZERO E.COLI. The e coli could have just as easily come from a number of other food products, however the plaintiffs picked raw milk, arbitrarily. To prevail in the courts in California you have to have evidence. Prediction - summary judgment for the defendant
I agree with Jon Beck -- NO EVIDENCE of this, and this woman tried to blame Organic Pastures who is doing a great thing by educating consumers on a great gift - raw, pasture fed milk. Yes, this child was made ill by something else, with raw milk being used the scapegoat. (FDA and CDC hate it because pharmaceutical companies would lose money if people aren't using prescription drugs. Keep the population sick and stupid - and misinformed) -- PS pasteurized/homogenized milk is nothing more than white water - it has NO nutritional value whatsoever. Healthy people don't spend money on prescription drugs, so people -- I ASK YOU TO FOLLOW THE MONEY...and see where all the misinformation really leads you!