Can TV cooks become food safety celebrities? or Have you spotted Doug Powell ranting?
"If you read Doug Powell’s FSnet e-mail news, you have probably spotted some of his rants against unsafe techniques demonstrated on television cooking shows."
So says Gary Acuff, president of the International Association for Food Protection in his June 2008 column about the poor food safety practices of celebrity chefs.
My rants are based on research, reviewed and published in Food Protection Trends, a monthly journal of … the International Association for Food Protection.
In 2004, my laboratory reported that, based on 60 hours of detailed viewing of television cooking shows, an unsafe food handling practice occurred about every four minutes, and that for every safe food handling practice observed, we observed 13 unsafe practices. The most common errors were inadequate hand washing and cross-contamination between raw and ready-to-eat foods. The abstract is below and available at http://www.foodsafety.ksu.edu/en/article-details.php?a=3&c=14&sc=102&id=842.
To answer Gary's question, is there something that can be done? After completing the initial research in 2002, I began writing about the topic, with snappy headlines like, Can TV cooks become food safety celebrities? One of my students at the time, Christian Battista, put together four, 3-minute greatest hits videos, depicting various practices we observed like cross-contamination and lack of handwashing. The videos were a hit.
.jpg)
Once the paper was published, it made headlines around the globe. Some folks at the Food Network in Canada gave me a call, and said they wanted to work with me and my lab, to enhance food safety on their shows.
I said sure.
I also kept showing the videos at my various public appearances.
And then the Food Network called again.
This time the folks at the other end were on a speakerphone -- and there was a lot of them. Lawyers, I suspect.
The Food Network people said if I ever showed the videos again they would sue my ass.
But YouTube didn't exist back then. And I'm in the U.S. now. Hmmm ….
Mathiasen, L.A., Chapman, B.J., Lacroix, B.J. and Powell, D.A. 2004. Spot the mistake: Television cooking shows as a source of food safety information, Food Protection Trends 24(5): 328-334.
Consumers receive information on food preparation from a variety of sources. Numerous studies conducted over the past six years demonstrate that television is one of the primary sources for North Americans. This research reports on an examination and categorization of messages that television food and cooking programs provide to viewers about preparing food safely. During June 2002 and 2003, television food and cooking programs were recorded and reviewed, using a defined list of food safety practices based on criteria established by Food Safety Network researchers. Most surveyed programs were shown on Food Network Canada, a specialty cable channel. On average, 30 percent of the programs viewed were produced in Canada, with the remainder produced in the United States or United Kingdom. Sixty hours of content analysis revealed that the programs contained a total of 916 poor food-handling incidents. When negative food handling behaviors were compared to positive food handling behaviors, it was found that for each positive food handling behavior observed, 13 negative behaviors were observed. Common food safety errors included a lack of hand washing, cross-contamination and time-temperature violations. While television food and cooking programs are an entertainment source, there is an opportunity to improve their content so as to promote safe food handling.
.jpg)
So says Gary Acuff, president of the International Association for Food Protection in his June 2008 column about the poor food safety practices of celebrity chefs.My rants are based on research, reviewed and published in Food Protection Trends, a monthly journal of … the International Association for Food Protection.
In 2004, my laboratory reported that, based on 60 hours of detailed viewing of television cooking shows, an unsafe food handling practice occurred about every four minutes, and that for every safe food handling practice observed, we observed 13 unsafe practices. The most common errors were inadequate hand washing and cross-contamination between raw and ready-to-eat foods. The abstract is below and available at http://www.foodsafety.ksu.edu/en/article-details.php?a=3&c=14&sc=102&id=842.
To answer Gary's question, is there something that can be done? After completing the initial research in 2002, I began writing about the topic, with snappy headlines like, Can TV cooks become food safety celebrities? One of my students at the time, Christian Battista, put together four, 3-minute greatest hits videos, depicting various practices we observed like cross-contamination and lack of handwashing. The videos were a hit.
Once the paper was published, it made headlines around the globe. Some folks at the Food Network in Canada gave me a call, and said they wanted to work with me and my lab, to enhance food safety on their shows.I said sure.
I also kept showing the videos at my various public appearances.
And then the Food Network called again.
This time the folks at the other end were on a speakerphone -- and there was a lot of them. Lawyers, I suspect.
The Food Network people said if I ever showed the videos again they would sue my ass.
But YouTube didn't exist back then. And I'm in the U.S. now. Hmmm ….
Mathiasen, L.A., Chapman, B.J., Lacroix, B.J. and Powell, D.A. 2004. Spot the mistake: Television cooking shows as a source of food safety information, Food Protection Trends 24(5): 328-334.
Consumers receive information on food preparation from a variety of sources. Numerous studies conducted over the past six years demonstrate that television is one of the primary sources for North Americans. This research reports on an examination and categorization of messages that television food and cooking programs provide to viewers about preparing food safely. During June 2002 and 2003, television food and cooking programs were recorded and reviewed, using a defined list of food safety practices based on criteria established by Food Safety Network researchers. Most surveyed programs were shown on Food Network Canada, a specialty cable channel. On average, 30 percent of the programs viewed were produced in Canada, with the remainder produced in the United States or United Kingdom. Sixty hours of content analysis revealed that the programs contained a total of 916 poor food-handling incidents. When negative food handling behaviors were compared to positive food handling behaviors, it was found that for each positive food handling behavior observed, 13 negative behaviors were observed. Common food safety errors included a lack of hand washing, cross-contamination and time-temperature violations. While television food and cooking programs are an entertainment source, there is an opportunity to improve their content so as to promote safe food handling.
Trackbacks (2)
Links to blogs that reference this article
Trackback URL
http://barfblog.foodsafety.ksu.edu/admin/trackback/73786
http://barfblog.foodsafety.ksu.edu/admin/trackback/73786
BarfBlog -
July 28, 2008 8:02 PM
I’ve never been much of a fan of cooking shows. The chefs talk, they cook, they even sometimes teach poor food safety. Celebrity chef Jamie Oliver has taken the typical format of a cooking show and added an extra twist;...
BarfBlog -
September 14, 2008 10:19 PM
Last week, researchers at Texas Tech gushed in a press release about the food safety errors on cooking shows broadcast by the Food Network. “Researchers analyzed 49 shows airing over a two-week period and used 17 different coded categories: six...
Post A Comment / Question
Use this form to add a comment to this entry.
Send To A Friend
Use this form to send this entry to a friend via email.
I watch several cooking shows but only one religiously - "Good Eats". Though far from perfect Alton Brown includes in his show issues about cross contamination e.g. using separate cutting boards for chicken, raw vegetables and cooked; washing hands, wearing gloves - though he likes to soak and wash produce in his sink (yuck!). I especially enjoy his depictions of the USDA and FDA (referred to as the food police) - men (and women) in black with dark shades and walkie talkies, whenever he talks about standards and temperature requirements. He also gets sidelined by the show's "lawyers" when he talks about using raw ingredients as raw such as eggs and beef (tartar). Rachal Ray makes me cringe the most!
Hi Doug,
I teach College to Environmental Health Students(Canadian curriculum) in the Middleast(Qatar) and utilize food safety celeb.shows to illustrate many food safety mistakes-mostly Jamie Oliver and the Iron Chef..I am a little careful though viewing the pork shows!!!..Awesome. this article is great way to reinforce this activity.
Keep it coming..love it...
Allan Stirling MPH, CPHI(c)
URL posted..
The real mistake is wasting your life watching these idiots on TV.
Great Article! Really enjoyed it.