April 2008

  • Posted: April 30th, 2008 - 8:23pm by Doug Powell

    On the seminal 1978 live album, You Had to Be There, Jimmy Buffett introduces one of his songs by saying (and this is a paraphrase cause my turntable is in a garage in Guelph and Chapman took all my good vinyl),

    "People ask me, how can you write those sensitive songs and then that trash, and I say, sometimes I feel real sensitive and sometimes I feel real trashy."


    That's how I approach barfblog. Sometimes I've got information that I just have to get out there that's snarky, insightful and relevant, and sometimes I just feel real trashy.

    In the first year of barfblog.com, we posted 825 entries, increased the number of unique monthly visitors from 1,000 to 40,000 per month, got picked up by the N.Y. Times, David Letterman and dozens of other new and traditional media outlets, and sold a few hundred T-shirts (it's better than door-to-door chocolate sales to fund students).

    We influenced the formation of public policy in many ways but our favorite was getting mentioned in the Wales E. coli inquiry, where I used the Bill Murray Groundhog Day analogy. And I got to meet Bill Murray in Manhattan and give him a poop shirt. Showing that microwaves may be a lousy way to cook pot pies was kinda fun. Safest food in the world? Shurley you must be joking.

    The Internet means, unlike Jimmy in 1978, you don't have to be here … in Manhattan (Kansas). But you can subscribe. http://barfblog.foodsafety.ksu.edu/subscribe.html

    What's next? You'll find out soon enough.

    And I'm still with that girl.


    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    None  |  0 Comments
    Barfblog, Doug Powell
  • Posted: April 30th, 2008 - 7:02pm by Doug Powell

    The N.Y. Post reports that for just $216, Shizuka Bernstein will slather your face in feces for a full 50 minutes -- what she calls the "Geisha Facial" -- at her Midtown New York spa, Shizuka.

    It's bird poop.

    The ancient Japanese cleanser - geishas and kabuki dancers have been using the bird poop to wash off their heavy white makeup since the 18th century - contains guanine, which supposedly removes pollutants and blackheads, and helps even out skin tone.

    The exotic excrement comes in a powder form, directly from Japan, and is sterilized with UV light to kill bacteria.


    Marilyn Phillips, a 58-yearold Upper West Sider who had a Geisha Facial late last week, said,

    "I figure if poop was good for the soil, it's good for your face. And it doesn't smell at all. I'd say hair coloring smells way worse."

    32-year-old massage therapist Andrea Nieto who went in for the facial last week, said,

    "You wouldn't even know it was nightingale droppings. And after, my skin was softer than it had been in a really long time. And it looked clearer to me, too. But you gotta wonder how they figured to use these things. Who put 2 and 2 together like that?"



    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 30th, 2008 - 5:01pm by Doug Powell

    Albert Hofmann, the mystical Swiss chemist who gave the world LSD, the most powerful psychotropic substance known, died Tuesday at his hilltop home near Basel, Switzerland. He was 102.

    I mention this because a lot of people come to barfblog because of this groovy LSD-inspired picture. And Amy and I watched a fairly heady documentary about psychedlics last week.

    According to the obituary in the N.Y. Times:

    Dr. Hofmann first synthesized the compound lysergic acid diethylamide in 1938 but did not discover its psychopharmacological effects until five years later, when he accidentally ingested the substance that became known to the 1960s counterculture as acid.

    He then took LSD hundreds of times, but regarded it as a powerful and potentially dangerous psychotropic drug that demanded respect. More important to him than the pleasures of the psychedelic experience was the drug’s value as a revelatory aid for contemplating and understanding what he saw as humanity’s oneness with nature. That perception, of union, which came to Dr. Hofmann as almost a religious epiphany while still a child, directed much of his personal and professional life.

    “It happened on a May morning — I have forgotten the year — but I can still point to the exact spot where it occurred, on a forest path on Martinsberg above Baden,” he wrote in “LSD: My Problem Child.” “As I strolled through the freshly greened woods filled with bird song and lit up by the morning sun, all at once everything appeared in an uncommonly clear light.

    “It shone with the most beautiful radiance, speaking to the heart, as though it wanted to encompass me in its majesty. I was filled with an indescribable sensation of joy, oneness and blissful security.”

    He earned his Ph.D. there in 1929, when he was just 23. He then took a job with Sandoz Laboratories in Basel, attracted by a program there that sought to synthesize pharmacological compounds from medicinally important plants.

    It was during his work on the ergot fungus, which grows in rye kernels, that he stumbled on LSD, accidentally ingesting a trace of the compound one Friday afternoon in April 1943. Soon he experienced an altered state of consciousness similar to the one he had experienced as a child.

    On the following Monday, he deliberately swallowed a dose of LSD and rode his bicycle home as the effects of the drug overwhelmed him. That day, April 19, later became memorialized by LSD enthusiasts as “bicycle day.”



    Your rating: None (1 vote)
    Bookmark and Share
    Wacky and Weird  |  0 Comments
    Albert Hofmann, Lsd
  • Posted: April 30th, 2008 - 3:20pm by Doug Powell

    Howard Levitt, counsel to Lang Michener LLP, an employment lawyer who practises in seven Canadian provinces and author of The Law of Dismissal for Human Resources Professionals, writes that he is a McDonald's convert.

    Levitt says that rather then succumb to the human rights "police," McDonald's fought back to protect the right of Canadians to eat safe food. It and Canadians lost.

    What Levitt learned from this decision is McDonald's is a stickler for cleanliness: Employees must wash their hands after every break, after cleaning their work area, before entering the production area, before putting on gloves, after shaking hands, after touching a door handle and on it goes. It is so focused on being sanitary that apart from all the previously mentioned instances, a bell goes off every hour, telling employees to wash their hands.

    Besides good corporate citizenry, this reflects the law. It ensured McDonalds complied with the B.C. Health Act and the B.C. Centre for Disease Control's Food Protection Guidelines.

    But Beena Dat could not comply. A skin condition prevented her from wearing gloves or regularly washing her hands. She went on disability and unsuccessfully attempted to return to work three separate times. Her specialist, Dr. Kit-son, opined he had no doubt, if she attempted to return to work, her "hands would disintegrate in a week." She could not return to any job involving exposure to soap and water, in his view, thereby eliminating "restaurant work of any kind."

    Dat complained to the B.C. Human Rights Tribunal who appointed Judy Parrack to decide the case, who decided Mc-Donald's should have cross-examined the specialist rather than taking his medical report at face value.

    She also considered whether it was possible pieces of different jobs could have been extracted to create a position Ms. Dat could perform without frequently having to wash her hands.

    This is despite Ms. Parrack's acknowledging all jobs at Mc-Donald's require handwashing and, depending on how busy a section is, any position might quickly take over for another.

    Notably, Ms. Parrack found McDonald's liable for not attempting to construct such a position and awarded $50,000 in damages, including $25,000 for injury to Ms. Dat's "dignity, feelings and self-respect."

    Worst of all, McDonald's was ordered to "cease the discriminatory conduct or similar conduct and refrain from committing such conduct in the future." One might think consumer safety should supercede the right of an employee with unclean hands!


    A colleague says maybe the judge should eat at McDonald's and be served only with dirty hands.

    A Jason Lee stink palm pretzel, perhaps?
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Handwashing  |  0 Comments
    Mcdonald's
  • Posted: April 29th, 2008 - 4:34am by Doug Powell

    Scientists in the UK are seeking 150 women to eat chocolate every day for a year in the cause of medical research.

    The trial, at the University of East Anglia in Norwich, eastern England, will test whether a natural compound found in cocoa, the main ingredient of chocolate, could cut the risk of heart disease among women with diabetes.

    A Belgian confectionist has created the special chocolate bar containing high levels of flavonoids -- a plant compound that has been shown to reduce heart risk factors -- to be used in the experiment. Soy, another natural source of flavonoids, has also been added to the bar.

    Participants, who must be postmenopausal women under the age of 70, will have their risk of heart disease tested on five occasions during the year to see whether change occurs.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 29th, 2008 - 4:00am by Doug Powell

    City council in Windsor, Ontario (Canada) wants to make it illegal to vomit in public in an attempt to control late-night rowdiness.

    Council was also set to discuss a mandatory 2 a.m. closing-time for hotdog vendors.

    Apparently that's to keep munchie-driven zombies from roaming the streets.

    Patrick Lacey, 25, said,

    "What are they really going to do about vomiting in public? …  you can't stop someone from throwing up. Throwing up in public is embarrassing enough as it is; you don't need to get arrested."


    I can't wait for the next norovirus outbreak to hit Windsor.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Wacky and Weird  |  0 Comments
    Ontario, Vomit
  • Posted: April 28th, 2008 - 9:59am by Ben Chapman

    The Independant (UK) ( had an assortment of free range egg articles yesterday, including one from Joanna Lumley. Doug says that Joanna Lumley is famous; in a Coronation Street kind of way, I guess.

    Lumley writes that: Sixty-two per cent of hens in the UK still endure life sentences of frustration and deprivation in the battery cage. How can we let such cruelty continue? For the past two years, Compassion in World Farming has been engaging with the corporate world, persuading big players to abandon battery eggs and pledge to use eggs from more humane systems – at least from barn-kept hens, though free-range is best.

    Celebs getting involved with poultry standards isn't a new issue in the UK: back in January, Jamie Oliver and Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall took part in documentaries discussing poultry-raising standards and urging the public to switch to consumption of a more humane product.  Soon after the documentaries aired, Joanna Blythman (Jan 13, 2008) wrote that she didn't see the latest celebrity chef campaign yielding any better results [than past efforts]:

    The current round of public breast-beating on factory-farmed poultry provokes a sense of déja vu. If Britain really was concerned enough to support more progressive farming methods with its purse, then we would have seen an improvement in animal welfare by now. 

    But Blythman was apparently wrong.  In February it was reported that sales of factory-farmed chickens slumped post-documentary campaign to raise awareness implore consumers to pay more to improve the animals' welfare.  According to the Independent (Feb 28, 2008):

    Sales of free-range poultry shot up by 35 per cent last month compared with January 2007, while sales of standard indoor birds fell by 7 per cent, according to a survey of 25,000 shoppers by the market research company TNS.

    Celeb endorsements of food issues isn't strictly a British tactic either. Pam Anderson was famously linked to PETA animal welfare protests at KFC outlets a few years ago and maybe the threat of these protests resulted in Burger King's animal welfare systems?  In a Burger King press release PETA Vice President, Bruce Friedrich was quoted as saying “The BURGER KING brand’s influence has moved the entire animal industry. The availability of cage free products is growing, a credit to BKC’s leadership on the issue.”  California, hot bed of US celebrity action will be voting on animal welfare legislation, "The Prevention of Farm Animal Cruelty Act" which would mandate roomier housing for pregnant sows, veal calves and laying hens.

    The message to the food industry is that celebs (no matter how minor, or how British) can make a stir (whether around animal welfare, local diets, food safety, etc.) and really affect purchasing habits.  So be prepared and find a way to work alongside them on the issues; you can't ignore them.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 28th, 2008 - 9:12am by Doug Powell

    From pepperoni to prosciutto, sausages and cured meats from continental Europe are going to be targeted by UK inspectors amid several Salmonella incidents reported to the Health Protection Agency and linked to the products.

    French, Italian, Belgium, and Dutch markets are listed as targets in the briefing documents sent to food safety departments across Sussex. Farmers' markets and town markets will also be visited for samples.

    Inspectors across Sussex will take hundreds of samples of biltong, continental sausages such as salamis, pepperoni and mettwurst and cured meat like proscuitto during the next 12 months.

    Apart from specialist meats, egg mixes from restaurants and takeaways as well as packaged nuts will be tested.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Food Safety Policy  |  0 Comments
    Mystery Meat, Uk
  • Posted: April 27th, 2008 - 8:21pm by Doug Powell

    Swanky Auckland restaurant Euro served up a recipe for Metro Food Critic Testicles in an advertisement that finished -- "balls to them" -- before inviting people to try the place for themselves.

    The Nourish Group, which owns Auckland restaurants Euro and the Jervois Steak House and Saloon, and Pravda in Wellington, took out a full page ad in the Herald on Sunday banning what it claimed were "out of step" Metro reviewers from its premises after the restaurants were left out of a top 50 list of New Zealand eateries.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 27th, 2008 - 4:29pm by Doug Powell

    Not just the title of the 1991 album by Canadian rockers, The Tragically Hip, road apples is slang for horse shit.

    And Los Angeles has lots of it (and doesn't even freeze to use as a makeshit hockey puck).

    Bloomberg reports that zoning restrictions have resulted in the closure of all the traditional "manure mulcher" businesses in Los Angeles County, forcing stables to haul their horse poop to ordinary land fills, which charge up to US$47 a ton, or roughly five times what the mulchers used to charge.

    L.A. County is home to about 45,000 horses and almost 10 million people. Horses generate an estimated US$900-million a year in revenue from things such as riding lessons, blacksmiths, feed sales.

    But more about the Hip.

    Released in 1991, the original title of the record was Saskadelphia, but the record label considered it "too Canadian." As a joke, they re-titled it Road Apples, slang for horse dung. After the album was released, they created the Another Roadside Attraction festival -- another joke referring to "road apples."

    The album is often cited by fans and critics as the band's finest work. As with most Tragically Hip albums, Canadian themes appear in the album's lyrics. "Three Pistols" is an English translation of the name of the Quebec town Trois-Pistoles, and refers to Tom Thomson, a Canadian painter, as well as Remembrance Day, the Canadian commemorative day for its war dead. "The Luxury" refers to the fleur-de-lis, provincial symbol of Quebec, while "Born in the Water" is about the controversy surrounding Ontario municipalities (particularly Sault Ste. Marie) declaring themselves "English-only" in the dying days of the Meech Lake Accord debate.


    Three Pistols is used in the opening and closing credits of our safefoodcafe videos. Like this one:


    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 27th, 2008 - 10:00am by Ben Chapman

    NBCSandiego reported yesterday that the cases of Hep A linked to a La Mesa Chipotle has reached 14.  The story says that most concern is over anyone who dined at the restaurant located at 8005 Fletcher Parkway between March 1 and April 22. Officials were cited as saying blood samples taken so far from restaurant employees have not shown any recent Hepatitis A infections.

    With 14 cases and so far no employee testing for any signs of Hep A, I wonder if this outbreak is linked to a common food vehicle from a supplier, or one mixed/prepared in store.    Wonder if there has been a spike in what is thought to be sporadic Hep A cases associated with other outlets suppliers sent product to.

    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Hepatitis A  |  1 Comment
    Chipotle, Outbreak
  • Posted: April 25th, 2008 - 10:27pm by Doug Powell

    Health officials closed the Acapulco Mexican Restaurante in Xenia, Ohio, for several hours Friday after 23 people reported becoming sick.

    Mark McDonnell, with the Greene County Health Department, said,

    "We strongly suspect it's the Norwalk virus simply because of the time frame. People reported getting sick within 24 hours, and it only lasts 24 to 48 hours. … We had a couple of employees ill last week, and they might have come back on a little too early and were still shedding the virus."

    Health officials ordered workers to sanitize the restaurant before it reopened at 3 p.m. Friday afternoon. Inspectors said the restaurant meets all its requirements and is now safe for customers.



    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Norovirus  |  0 Comments
    Acapulco, Ohio
  • Posted: April 25th, 2008 - 8:50am by Doug Powell

    State health officials are continuing to investigate an E. coli outbreak in Sarpy County, Omaha, that sickened 14 people — including a 7-year-old — and sent four people to the hospital.

    State epidemiologist Dr. Tom Safranek said the outbreak was caused by roast beef served at a reception hall in Sarpy County for a private gathering of 50 to 60 people on March 26.  Safranek further noted the meat was prepared at a person's home and brought to the event, but he would not say where the meal was served or what the gathering was for.

    Despite the sense of kinship and best intentions, there have been at least 37 reported outbreaks of foodborne illness associated with homecooked products and community dinners in North America since 1973 (http://foodsafety.ksu.edu/en/article-details.php?a=3&c=32&sc=419&id=890).
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 24th, 2008 - 9:53pm by Doug Powell

    The San Diego County Health and Human Services Agency (HHSA) reports six additional cases of Hepatitis A linked to possible exposure at a Chipotle restaurant in La Mesa, bringing the total number of cases to 12.

    The County recommends that individuals who dined at the restaurant between March 1 and April 22, 2008 -- and are symptomatic for Hepatitis A -- see their physician to be screened for the illness.

    Wilma Wooten, M.D., M.P.H., County of San Diego Public Health Officer, said,

    “Hepatitis A is a vaccine-preventable illness. The key to prevention also includes appropriate and frequent hand-washing."

    Monty Moran, president and chief operating officer of Chipotle, said,


    “We continue to partner with the County of San Diego as they investigate the cause of this illness. Employees tested to date have been negative for Hepatitis A. Our restaurant has received ‘A’ ratings in all five inspections in the last five months.”

    Keep poop out of food. Wash your damn hands.


    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Hepatitis A  |  2 Comments
    Chipotle, San Diego
  • Posted: April 23rd, 2008 - 4:54pm by Doug Powell

    Salmonella left 19 people hospitalized and 146 sick after eating at a popular Tuzla diner last Friday. The large number of patients overwhelmed hospital facilities.

    City authorities ordered the closure of the diner and investigated its food and facilities.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 23rd, 2008 - 4:21pm by Doug Powell

    The San Diego Health and Human Services Agency and County Department of Environmental Health are investigating six cases of hepatitis A linked to a La Mesa Chipotle restaurant. …

    Hepatitis A is a result of poor hygiene. Health officials say that victims are exposed when an individual consumes water or food contaminated with the stool of someone with the virus.


    These hepatitis A cases are a weekly occurrence in the U.S. A food worker parties in Mexico or the Dominican or Honduras, where hepatitis A is endemic. Food worker comes home, is fine for two weeks, then spends the next two weeks crapping out virus. And unless food worker  is really diligent about handwashing, she's spreading virus-containing poop on food -- especially fresh produce or salads. After four weeks, food worker turns yellow and goes to the doctor where a diagnosis is made. Then the clinics start. In this case, a food worker has not been identified as the source -- yet.

    Get vaccinated for hepatitis A. And dude, wash your damn hands.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Hepatitis A  |  0 Comments
    Chipotle, San Diego
  • Posted: April 23rd, 2008 - 11:04am by Ben Chapman

    Katie Byard at Ohio.com reports this morning that the number of potential norovirus cases linked to a Kent, Ohio Chipotle has grown to 435.  The story also says that Chipotle has established a claims process to reimburse the related medical expenses of those who became ill (good move on their part).
    The outbreak also inspired our infosheet this week.  We hope that the infosheet generates discussion amongst food handlers about norovirus outbreaks and what can be done to reduce the risk.

    Click here to download the infosheet.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 22nd, 2008 - 9:10am by Doug Powell

    The traditional handshaking ceremony that takes place after assemblies at Bedales School in Steep, near Petersfield, has been temporarily scrapped amid fears it could spread infection.

    Headteacher Keith Budge said he made the decision after being told on Sunday that a 15-year-old student had been diagnosed with E. coli O157.

    "We have already checked hygiene arrangements across the school and will be advising all staff and students to follow good hygiene practice. The school's traditional handshaking ceremony after assembly has been suspended until we get the all-clear."
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 21st, 2008 - 11:36pm by Doug Powell

    The Chipotle restaurant across from Kent State University in Ohio appears to be the source of hundreds of norovirus illnesses this weekend.

    One report cited Kent health officials as saying that 432 people had reported norovirus symptoms as of Monday afternoon.

    Victims began showing up at local hospitals Thursday evening and the restaurant closed Friday.

    Many of those who got ill were Kent State University students. The restaurant is directly across from the campus, and students who took part in a recent American Red Cross blood drive received a coupon for free food at Chipotle.

    Kent Health Commissioner John Ferlito said Saturday the health department and the Denver-based restaurant chain agreed to switch employees out of concern that the outbreak might be caused by a sick employee. Several of the restaurant's employees had been ill, but they also had eaten the restaurant's food.


    Chipotle spokesman Chris Arnold said in a statement Saturday,

    "Local health department officials have found no violations in inspections of our Kent State restaurant conducted after this incident was first reported, and again in an inspection this morning. We have reopened our restaurant with their full support. We have taken preventative steps that meet or exceed health department requirements, and will continue to assist them in their investigation."

    If someone wants to check out Kent State University and Chipotle on Facebook, I bet there's lots of stories to hear.

    Antibiotics? How about norovirus?

    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Norovirus  |  2 Comments
    Antibiotics, Chipotle
  • Posted: April 21st, 2008 - 10:01pm by Doug Powell

    Julie Schmit of USA Today reports that federal food-safety officials are considering whether labels on some frozen chicken products adequately inform consumers that the chicken is raw and provide sufficient cooking instructions.

    Minnesota health officials said that stuffed chicken entrees — which look cooked because they're breaded and prebrowned so that the breading sticks — are blamed for five salmonella outbreaks since 1998 that sickened 71 people.

    The latest outbreak, in Minnesota in March, occurred even though the products' labels changed more than a year ago to more explicitly state that the chicken is uncooked. "

    David Goldman, assistant administrator for the U.S. Department of Agriculture, said,

    "We've done everything we think is appropriate, but if consumer behavior hasn't changed, we have to deal with that."

    Carlota Medus, epidemiologist with the Minnesota Department of Health, said, "They look precooked, plus they are marketed as convenience foods," and that consumers may think the chicken is cooked and only reheat it, which doesn't kill bacteria.

    Of the four consumers sickened in the recent outbreak, two thought the product was precooked. Three used a microwave, even though the label warns not to, Medus says. Conventional oven-cooking is advised because they cook more uniformly than microwaves.

    The outbreak was linked to chicken cordon bleu and chicken breast stuffed with cheese from Serenade Foods. Serenade spokeswoman Janelle Deatsman said,

    "We think it's important consumers follow label directions."

    Do people read instructions, and are the instructions understood? Are the instructions in multiple languages? Does understanding translate into safe handling behavior?



    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 21st, 2008 - 4:40pm by Doug Powell

    The first time I met Amy was Oct. 24, 2005.

    Ben and I had arrived in Manhattan (Kansas) a couple of days earlier, and our first official function was to serve as the entertainment at a meeting of the Canadian Studies club at Kansas State University. They wanted to see what real hosers were like, and Ben and I wanted free sandwiches, so it worked out well.

    Amy said something about being a French professor and I said French food sucked.

    At some point we got talking about dogs and food safety, and Amy mentioned that she let her dog sleep on her bed (below) and I said that was a microbiological nightmare.

    Or something like that.

    Fred Landeg, the U.K.'s acting Chief Veterinary Officer, said today dogs should not be allowed to sleep in their owners’ beds or even in the same room in case they pass on diseases, such as campylobacter and salmonella as well as exotic diseases.

    "As a veterinary surgeon I would never advise people to keep dogs in their bedroom."

    I was being dramatic when I first met Amy. Our dogs sleep in the bedroom but not on the bed.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Food Safety Policy  |  1 Comment
    Dogs, Sleep, Uk, Zoonoses
  • Posted: April 21st, 2008 - 4:11pm by Doug Powell

    The Australian version of the top-5 food safety myths is as follows:

    • The three-second rule
    If you drop food on the floor, pick it up within three seconds or so and it will be fine to eat. Wrong.

    • Seafood is dodgy
    Seafood is no more likely to cause food poisoning than other meats, and in Australia, strict regulations apply to its handling and storage.

    • It's OK to leave cooked rice/pasta out of the fridge
    When these foods enter the temperature "danger zone" of 5-60 degrees, Bacillus cereus can form heat-resistant spores and a heat-resistant toxin.

    • Dairy products cause phlegm
    Dairy Australia and the National Asthma Council Australia say that this myth is not supported by scientific evidence, citing a comprehensive review in the Journal of the American College of Nutrition.

    • Mould on cheese and jam is not dangerous
    Moulds can penetrate more deeply than the eye can see, so what looks like a small patch on your chunky raspberry jam or vintage tasty cheese might be a lot larger.

    I didn't know phlegm was a food safety issue, but Australia is a large exporter of dairy products so I guess they care (what would formally be called an example of value judgments in risk assessment).

    What's your top-5 food safety myths?

    Mine would be (brought to you by top-10 records):

    • Meat is cooked when the juices run clear
    Color is a lousy indicator of doneness. Use a thermometer.

    • It's local/organic/natural/domestic so it's safe
    Can be, but need to provide evidence of microbiological safety of any food, from around the corner or around the globe.

    • The last meal eaten, especially if it was at a fast-food joint, caused my foodborne illness
    Nope, incubation times for most microorganisms -- except some toxins and viruses -- are at lot longer than a few hours.

    • Washing fresh produce will make it safe
    It may be frustrating for consumers and retailers, but there's not much to be done once produce leaves the farm and packing shed. The risk has to be reduced on the farm.
    • The bathrooms are clean so the food is safe
    I'm not sure how big this is, but Ben says he hears it all the time, and I can't think up a fifth, so going with it.
    How about, certified/verified/HACCPified/inspected/audited don't means that much unless there is a culture of food safety present farm-to-fork, 24/7.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 20th, 2008 - 3:08pm by Doug Powell

    America has the safest food supply in the world. True or False?

    It's impossible to say. The statistics don't exist to make such a claim. But that doesn't stop meatpackers, lobbyists, lawmakers and even government regulators who should know better, from repeating the claim every time there's a food-borne illness outbreak or major food recall.


    So says Philip Brasher, writing today in the Des Moines Register.

    Brasher says unfounded claims can undermine the credibility of the government and the industry and he cites barfblog.com and our special safest-food-in-the-world section at http://barfblog.foodsafety.ksu.edu/articles/safest-food-in-the-world/.

    Kansas State University Professor Doug Powell wrote on a blog where he tracks food safety news,

    "Bland blanket statements serve only to amplify rather than mollify consumers (concerns)."

    Brasher goes on to say that the problem with making these claims is that it's now impossible to compare one country's statistics to another country's, experts say. Most foodborne illnesses go unreported, so government agencies must come up with estimates of how many actually occur. How to do that varies.

    Paul Frenzen, a demographer with the Agriculture Department's Economic Research who specializes in food safety, said that even a factor that would seem relatively simple to measure, such as cases of food-related diarrhea, isn't easy to track because definitions vary, and there are also cultural differences between countries as to when victims of foodborne illness go to the doctor.

    Other countries offer universal health insurance, making it more likely that people will get to a doctor when they're sick.

    Brasher concludes that after the nation's largest meat recall was announced earlier this year, Agriculture Secretary Ed Schafer didn't claim that U.S. food is the world's safest. Instead, he said,

    "The United States enjoys one of the safest food supplies in the world."

    No one is going to argue with that.

    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 20th, 2008 - 2:14pm by Doug Powell

    Dallas Morning News columnist James Ragland tried to raise awareness of foodborne illness yesterday but instead perpetuated some of the worst myths -- that barfing is caused by the last food eaten and that fast-food burger joints are largely to blame.

    Ragland writes that on Monday,

    "I decided to swing through a popular fast-food restaurant to grab a burger, fries and a cold drink.

    Hours later, the burger grabbed back. My stomach tightened. A chill fell over me. Then sweat.

    If you've ever had food poisoning, you know what happened next.

    One recurring thought crossed my mind as my wife patiently dabbed a cold damp towel across my forehead: "Go into the kitchen, fetch the solid cast-iron skillet and whack me over the head with it!"

    By week's end, I was still struggling to get back to full strength, relying mostly on saltines and Gatorade."


    Foodborne illness sucks for anyone, and Ragland deserves credit for reporting on the topic and telling people how to report foodborne illness in Dallas. However, except for a few toxins, it's not the last meal that made someone like Ragland sick, and fast-food joints -- especially the popular ones -- have fairly good food safety systems; they have too, with so many outlets and so many people looking to make a fast buck. Incubation times for most foodborne ailments can be found in the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's Bad Bug Book at http://www.cfsan.fda.gov/~mow/app2.html.

    If you think food made you sick, here's what to do:

    • go to the doctor if necessary;

    • keep the food, in the fridge or freezer if necessary; and,

    • contact your local health department.



    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 20th, 2008 - 11:55am by Doug Powell

    About 90 children and staff at three primary schools in south Belfast are to be tested for the E. coli infection after a P1 pupil at Rosetta Primary School was confirmed as carrying the bug.

    Pupils at the school recently took part in a school excursion to an open farm near Belfast along with children from Cregagh and Holy Rosary primaries.


    The Eastern Health Board said other people who had contracted the infection in recent weeks had some contact with the farm.

    Children and pensioners are especially vulnerable to E. coli O157 which is normally found in the intestines of people and cattle and can be passed on by eating infected food and liquid.

    Not quite.

    E. coli O157 and other verotoxigenic E. coli are found in about 10 per cent of all ruminants -- cattle, sheep, goats, deer -- and outbreaks have been linked to each.

    So while the farm says,

    "We are confident that our intensive cleaning programme over the weekend will further reassure the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) on Monday and that we will immediately reopen for business,"

    it may not be that simple.

    There have been over 20 outbreaks of severe illness from petting zoos -- primarily contact with farm animals -- in the past decade.

    159 people, mainly children, were sickened with E. coli O157:H7 traced to a goat and a sheep at the petting zoo at the 1999 Western Fair in London, Ontario.

    Prof. Hugh Pennington of the U.K. has gone so far as to say that children under five (who are more vulnerable because of their still-developing immune systems) should be banned from visiting livestock farms because of the serious risk of acquiring E. coli O157:H7 infection from farm animals. Such a ban already exists in Sweden.

    In the fall of 1998, I accompanied one of my four daughters on a kindergarten trip to the farm (left). After petting the animals and touring the crops --I questioned the fresh manure on the strawberries --we were assured that all the food produced was natural. We then returned for unpasteurized apple cider. The host served the cider in a coffee urn, heated, so my concern about it being unpasteurized was abated. I asked: "Did you serve the cider heated because you heard about other outbreaks and were concerned about liability?" She responded, "No. The stuff starts to smell when it's a few weeks old and heating removes the smell."

    There is much to learn from interacting with animals
    , farms and the world. The challenge is to do so in a microbiologically safe manner.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    E. coli  |  0 Comments
    Farm Visits, Ireland
  • Posted: April 17th, 2008 - 9:21pm by Doug Powell

    Three high school students who thought they were being funny by sticking a bag of poop in a Sandy, Utah 7-Eleven microwave and cooking it for 10 minutes have been arrested.

    Earlier this week, police released surveillance video of three teens who walked into the convenience store near 2200 East and 9400 South, took out a one-gallon plastic bag with human feces inside and put it into the microwave while the clerk wasn't looking.

    The boys left the store, and the clerk figured out what had happened when a foul stench filled the building. The store had to be closed temporarily because of the odor.

    Sandy police Sgt. Victor Quezada said the surveillance video was broadcast by local news stations, investigators received numerous tips from callers, and that on Wednesday morning, five high school students were greeted by police as they arrived for school in the morning. Two of the boys eventually were released, while the other three, two aged 16 and a 17-year-old, were arrested for investigation of third-degree felony criminal mischief.

    The 7-Eleven figured out the video surveillance thing, but USDA says it's too complicated for slaughterhouses.


    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 17th, 2008 - 7:45pm by Doug Powell

    Dr. Raymond has spoken: the U.S. Department of Agriculture needs neither videocameras nor more inspectors to police slaughterhouses after the country's largest beef recall earlier this year.

    Everything is just fine.

    Raymond, the U.S. Department of Agriculture's undersecretary for food safety (right, on the left, at Marler's food safety bash last week), told a House subcommittee that USDA has enough food inspectors after hiring more than 190 last year and videotaping meat plant operations would be costly and practically difficult to implement, adding, "It's not as simple as a camera," and that the agency was "not stretched too thin."

    Raymond's response angered House members
    , who said the recall of beef slaughtered in the Hallmark/Westland plant in Chino, Calif., showed a need for improvements.

    The beef was recalled after the Humane Society of the United States released an undercover video showing the mistreatment of sick cows at the Westland/Hallmark plant in Chino, Calif.

    As I've said before, USDA may need to adopt some new inspection and investigative techniques if the HSUS can so easily document such grotesquely poor treatment of animals.

    And unlike 12th century France, USDA has access to the same video technology that a single undercover worker -- not the five USDA inspectors on-site -- was able to use to bring down a large corporation. Producers and processors who say their food is safe should be able to prove it. Producers and processors who say they treat animals humanely should be able to prove it.

    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 17th, 2008 - 12:05pm by Doug Powell

    When the residents of South Park awaken to discover they have no Internet service, and eventually determine there's no Internet to check why there's no Internet, they begin a Tom Joad-like trek to California, although in this case it's Silicon Valley.

    I was reminded of my own Internet dependence, which became clear during the great Manhattan (Kansas) ice storm of 2007. Or traveling in France last year, aimlessly walking around neighborhoods trying to pick up free Internet (hint, the French password protect everything).

    But I wouldn't trade it for John Adams-era communication, waiting for word of a French alliance to arrive by boat.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 17th, 2008 - 11:07am by Doug Powell

    Ryan learned on Top Chef last night that California-style tailgating doesn't play too well in the heartland -- or at least, Chicago.

    Accurately measuring whether food is safe or not is also not high on the Top Chef to-do list. Sure, the Australian dude (or New Zealand, the show refers to him interchangeably, which will equally please the Aussies and Kiwis) was chastised for being unsanitary -- cross contamination and double dipping -- but use a tip-sensitive digital thermometer to ensure safety and quality. Sick it in.

    Check out our youtube video of tailgaters at Kansas State's last home game - against Missouri -- back in Nov. 2007.



    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 16th, 2008 - 12:02pm by Ben Chapman

    This weeks infosheet is all about last weeks announcement of a Salmonella Agona outbreak linked to Malt-O-Meal cereal and what operators and food handlers need to know about it.

    Infosheet highlights:
    At least 23 people in 14 states have been sickened by the same strain of Salmonella found in breakfast cereals recalled by Malt-O-Meal.
    What can you do during this recall?
    -Ask at your store or restaurant about the use of any of these products
    -Remove the product from your shelves or stock room
    -Return the recalled product to where you purchased it or your supplier
    -For more information on the date codes of recalled products including pictures see: www.malt-o-meal.com/recallinfo/

    Click here to download the infosheet.

    The newest food safety infosheet, a graphical one-page food safety-related story directed at food handlers is also now available at foodsafetyinfosheets.ksu.edu. Infosheets are created weekly by iFSN and are posted in restaurants, retail stores, on farms and used in training throughout the world.  If you have any infosheet topic requests, or photos, please contact me at bchapman@uoguelph.ca.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Food Safety Policy  |  0 Comments
    Malt-o-meal
  • Posted: April 16th, 2008 - 6:22am by Doug Powell

    A mother writes in the blog of the New Jersey Star-Ledger that,
     
    "What began as a two-night getaway at a farm in Lancaster County, Pa., turned into a calamity of nightmarish proportions for me and my two kids when we drank raw milk.

    My friend and I took our children to a working farm during spring break. They milked cows, fed bottles of milk to calves and ran free on acres of land - a rarity for these city kids.

    They also drank the milk that was on the breakfast table, a milk I might add, that was the most silky and delicious any of us had ever tasted. We were told it was unpasteurized, but made to believe it was safe. (I assumed it was at least boiled).

    A day after returning home, we knew we had made a terrible mistake. The first to fall ill was my five-year-old daughter, who had a high fever, then stomach flu symptoms, then my four-year-old son, then me.

    My friend and her family had become violently ill as well. We spent seven days worried that our kids could dehydrate and forced them to drink gallons of Gatorade. My friend did get dehydrated and needed intravenous fluids in order to return to her job as a nurse.

    After a week of this torture, medical tests showed we had contracted campylobacter, a bacterial food poisoning that can be found in unpasteurized milk. The six of us were prescribed antibiotics.

    Thankfully, we're all going to be OK.

    To be fair, campylobacter can also be spread by contact with raw or undercooked poultry, as the farm owners later told us, but the likely culprit according to my doctor was the raw milk."

    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 15th, 2008 - 8:38pm by Doug Powell

    On March 22, 2008 the U.S. Food and Drug Administration advised consumers not to eat cantaloupes from a Honduran grower because they may have been contaminated with Salmonella.  The outbreak has so far caused over 50 illnesses in 16 states, and at least nine illnesses in Canada.  Warnings and recalls related to cantaloupes are common. This is largely due to their growing conditions and their porosity.

    A table of U.S. outbreaks related to the consumption of cantaloupe is available at: http://www.foodsafety.ksu.edu/articles/1183/cantaloupe_outbreaks_.pdf

    How can consumers enjoy cantaloupe without the burden of becoming sick?  The most important thing to do is to minimize the chances of contaminating the interior of the fruit.  This is done by preventing the rind from contaminating the inside of the cantaloupe, either by direct contact or by cross contamination.  There are different methods used for preparing a cantaloupe, but there is disagreement over which is the most effective technique.

    References:

    “Reducing Salmonella on cantaloupes and honeydew melons using wash practices applicable to postharvest handling, foodservice, and consumer preparation”. Tracy L. Parnell, Linda J. Harris, Trevor V. Suslow.  University of California.  International Journal of Food Microbiology 99 (2005) 59-70.

    “Effect of Sanitizer Treatments on Salmonella Stanley Attached to the Surface of Cantaloupe and Cell Transfer to Fresh-Cut Tissues during Cutting Practices”. Dike O. Ukuku and Gerald M. Sapers.  U.S. Department of Agriculture. Journal of Food Protection, Vol. 64, No. 9, 2001.




    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Salmonella  |  1 Comment
    Cantaloupe
  • Posted: April 15th, 2008 - 4:49pm by Doug Powell

    In October 2007, at least 270 people in 36 American states got sick with Salmonella after eating Banquet Pot Pies, leading to a national recall and prompting many to question the safety of microwave cooking. Since the outbreak, the manufacturer, ConAgra, has revamped their labeling to try to ensure proper microwave preparation by consumers.  But questions still loom whether these label changes are enough, and may leave people wondering how to properly cook using a microwave.

    For thick items that can’t be cut:
    ∑ use medium power;
    ∑ microwave for a longer period of time;
    ∑ stir, turn, or flip food halfway through to limit cold spots;
    ∑ let food stand for a couple minutes when finished microwaving; and,
    ∑ be cautious of bones (they can act as heat shields.

    There are many other variables that dictate how well food is cooked in the microwave, including:
    ∑ type of container;
    ∑ physical state of food (frozen or thawed);
    ∑ type of food;
    ∑ product geometry;
    ∑ moisture content;
    ∑ bone presence; and,
    ∑ microwave wattage.

    The wattage of a microwave is located on the back or inside the door.  Microwave power is grouped into high (1000 – 1300 W), medium (700-900 W) and low (500-600 W).  Many labels on microwave foods give cook times for high, medium and low wattage microwaves, so it is handy to know the wattage being used.

    There are hundreds of frozen, prepared products or meals, like pot pies, that may contain raw or fully cooked ingredients. The only way to know is to read labels carefully. Package labels may also contain instructions to cook to 165°F for poultry and 160°F for beef and other meats, and to verify doneness using a digital, tip-sensitive thermometer.  To be on the safe side, leftovers should reach 145°F.


    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Food Safety Policy  |  1 Comment
    Microwave
  • Posted: April 13th, 2008 - 11:19pm by Doug Powell

    The Dali Lama is at the hotel next door, Chris Rock is doing standup at a theatre down the street, and I'm sitting at Seattle University with a bunch of food safety geeks.

    Wouldn't have it any other way.

    What I learned from Marler's food safety conference in Seattle for the past two days is:

    • the supposed experts are as confused as mere mortals when it comes to food safety solutions;

    • faith-based food safety systems are as common as I thought they might be; and,

    • there's a whole lot of supposedly smart people who can't be bothered to edit themselves to their allotted time.

    Marketing food safety at retail may be a way to create a food safety culture from farm-to-fork.

    Oh, and they protest about everything in Seattle.


    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 12th, 2008 - 2:41pm by Doug Powell

    The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) today announced that at least 23 people in 14 states have been diagnosed with salmonellosis that was caused by the same strain of Salmonella that was found in the recently recalled unsweetened Puffed Rice and unsweetened Puffed Wheat Cereals produced by Malt-O-Meal.


    The recalled products were distributed nationally under the Malt-O-Meal brand name as well as under private label brands including Acme, America's Choice, Food Club, Giant, Hannaford, Jewel, Laura Lynn, Pathmark, Shaw's, ShopRite, Tops and Weis Quality. The cereals have "Best If Used By" dates from April 8, 2008 (coded as "APR0808") through March 18, 2009 (coded as "MAR1809").

    Consumers should throw out any product in their homes from these recalled lots. Grocery stores and other retailers should promptly remove the cereals from their shelves.

    Salmonella is a type of bacteria that can cause serious and sometimes fatal infections in young children, frail or elderly people, and others with weakened immune systems. Symptoms of foodborne Salmonella infection include nausea, vomiting, fever, diarrhea, and abdominal cramps. In persons with poor health or weakened immune systems, Salmonella can invade the bloodstream and cause life-threatening infections.

    Individuals who believe they may have experienced an illness consistent with the symptoms described above after consuming a puffed wheat or puffed rice cereal made by Malt-O-Meal should contact their health care practitioner immediately and report the illness to their state or local health authorities.


    On April 5, 2008, Malt-O-Meal voluntarily recalled the cereals because the company’s routine testing found Salmonella in a product produced on March 24, 2008.

    The FDA is working with Malt-O-Meal to determine the cause of the contamination and with the states and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to identify and prevent additional illnesses.

    A full list of recalled products can be found at www.malt-o-meal.com/recallinfo.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Salmonella  |  1 Comment
    Malt0o-meal
  • Posted: April 12th, 2008 - 9:45am by Ben Chapman

    Flick Direct is reporting today that Kenny Baker, best known for his role as R2-D2 in Star Wars was fell ill on a flight from the US to England on Thursday and was rushed to hospital immediately after landing at the airport.  Flick Direct  goes on to say that a family member said that he was recovering last night and expected to be home in a few days.  "Kenny's conscious and talking, hopefully hell be absolutely fine", said one relative.  Kenny played R2-D2 in all 6 of the Star Wars films.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Celebrity  |  0 Comments
    Illness, R2d2, Star, Wars
  • Posted: April 11th, 2008 - 6:02pm by Doug Powell

    Philip Brasher of the Des Moines Register reported from Seattle this morning that USDA’s undersecretary for food safety, Richard Raymond, said he’s determined to increase testing for E. coli contamination before he leaves office, adding,

    "We need to address this tougher problem and take some moves there to help protect the American public."

    Raymond, a physician who was formerly the chief medical officer in Nebraska, said results from some public health laboratories shows illnesses form non-O157 strains of E. coli are “at least as prevalent” as O157 illnesses. He said the non-O157 strains are harder to detect.

    I'm at the same conference, Who's Minding the Store? - The Current State of Food Safety and How It Can Be Improved, hosted by lawyer and barfblog sugar daddy Bill Marler.

    Washington  Governor Christine Gregoire (right) gave the food safety luncheon address.

    I chatted with the affable Dr. Raymond after his presentation, and asked him if USDA would consider using video cameras to augment veterinary inspection in slaughterhouses. He said, "ask me after next Thursday."

    Raymond, and several of the other speakers stated that the political-media focus on a single food inspection agency was a distraction.

    I agree. Whatever is done, it should reduce the number of sick people. That's the measure that counts, and one where progress has stalled.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 11th, 2008 - 5:49pm by Amy Hubbell

    I’m a reformed medium-rare hamburger eater. Before I met Doug, I always wanted my hamburgers pink in the middle and frankly had no clue that this was a potentially risky habit. Now that I’ve learned hamburger needs to be cooked to 160 F to be safe, however, I rarely eat hamburger unless Doug cooks it at home. That’s the only way I can assure that the cook is using a meat thermometer and knows how to properly do so.

    Tonight, though, I’m in Buffalo, NY and I had dinner with two British friends in a rowdy Irish pub. While I intended to order salad, the pickings were few on the menu and I settled on a cheeseburger with fries. The waitress asked me, “How do you want that cooked.” Somewhat startled and without my food safety arsenal beside me, I said, “Medium.” I hate well-done hamburger because of the texture, but I wanted my burger safe. How could I tell her that?

    My burger came and was very medium rare looking … very pink in the middle and done on the outside. I ate it. The whole thing. And it tasted good. And now I’m thinking about my foolish behavior and wondering if I’ll get e. coli. I know that color is a lousy indicator and I know it’s not likely I’ll get sick. But without the thermometer, how can you be sure?



    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 11th, 2008 - 12:46pm by Doug Powell

    "Raw milk is like a magic food for children."

    So says Sally Fallon, president of the Weston A. Price Foundation.

    She adds.

    "Without the green grass, you're missing a lot of vitamins. Also, it's much safer. When cows are eating green grass, you don't find pathogens in their milk."

    With such statements, public advocacy becomes public health risk.

    The natural reservoirs for E. coli O157:H7 and other verotoxigenic E. coli is the intestines of all ruminants, including cattle -- grass or grain-fed -- sheep, goats, deer and the like. The final report of the fall 2006 spinach outbreak identifies nearby grass-fed beef cattle as the likely source of the E. coli O157:H7 that sickened 200 and killed 4.

    A table of raw dairy outbreaks is available at http://www.foodsafety.ksu.edu/articles/384/RawMilkOutbreakTable.pdf

    Kids are often the ones that get sick.

    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 10th, 2008 - 9:44pm by Doug Powell

    The Centers for Disease Control reported today that foodborne illness remains a significant public health issue in the U.S., with Salmonella infections increasingly problematic.

    "Although significant declines in the incidence of certain foodborne pathogens have occurred since 1996, these declines all occurred before 2004," the CDC reported (http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5714a2.htm).

    "Outbreaks caused by contaminated peanut butter, frozen pot pies, and a puffed vegetable snack in 2007 underscore the need to prevent contamination of commercially produced products. The outbreak associated with turtle exposure highlights the importance of animals as a nonfood source of human infections. To reduce the incidence of Salmonella infections, concerted efforts are needed throughout the food supply chain, from farm to processing plant to kitchen."

    "Food safety is a continuing problem that starts at the farm and continues through the food chain all the way to the kitchen," Dr. Robert Tauxe, deputy director of CDC's Division of Foodborne, Bacterial and Mycotic Diseases, said during a teleconference.

    Given that rates of foodborne infection haven't changed significantly in the past three years, more needs to be done to improve food safety, Tauxe said "We have to be vigilant about hygiene practices and prevention all along the way to reduce the risk of foodborne infection."

    "There's just way too many sick people," said Dr. Douglas Powell, an associate professor and scientific director of the International Food Safety Network at Kansas State University.

    " The CDC data show existing efforts to reduce fodborne illness have stalled," said Powell, who also publishes barfblog.com. "We need new messages using new media to really create a culture that values microbiologically safe food."
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 9th, 2008 - 9:26pm by Doug Powell

    After three weeks of a boil-water advisory, the 8,500 residents were hoping for the all-clear today, so they could have a shower, brush their teeth, and maybe even a glass of water without hauling 5-gallon carboys of water around the house.

    Oh-oh.

    The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, called in to help with the outbreak of Salmonellas that has so far sickened 389, found two different parasites -- giardia and cryptosporidium -- present in the water system before it was flushed with high doses of chlorine last week.

    The city remains on a "boil order" requiring residents to boil water before drinking it or using it for cooking.

    A thorough investigation into the intricacies of a municipal water supply becoming contaminated can be found in the Walkerton Commission of Inquiry, held after E. coli O157:H7 got into the water supply of Walkerton, Ontario in 2000, sickening half the town of 5,000 and killing seven.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Salmonella  |  1 Comment
    Alamosa, Water
  • Posted: April 9th, 2008 - 3:36pm by Doug Powell

    Meatingplace.com was first to report on plans by USDA to start testing ground beef and ground beef component samples for non-O157 Shiga Toxin-Producing E. coli (STECs) to determine whether to declare them adulterants.

    (A couple of relevant outbreak tables involving non-O157 STECs are available at:
    http://barfblog.foodsafety.ksu.edu/2007/10/articles/e-coli/nono157-stec-meeting/)

    Officials from USDA's Food Safety and Inspection Service told about 200 participants at a public meeting on Wednesday the agency will test both samples that test positive and those that test negative for E. coli O157:H7, but production lots will not be recalled, seized or detained if they only test positive for non-O157 STECs. The data is being generated only for study purposes at this time.

    USDA will issue a public notice to announce a start date, which has not been determined. FSIS Deputy Assistant Administrator Daniel Engeljohn said the agency will assess the testing data "over a limited timeframe sufficient to ascertain the general likelihood of the presence of selected non-O157 STECs."

    "Based on the evidence that we develop from our testing, as well as other available evidence, we will decide whether to declare selected non-O157 STECs to be adulterants," he said in a presentation prepared for the group.

    Elizabeth Hagen, FSIS executive associate for Public Health, said the testing will focus on six groups of E. coli bacteria — O26, O111, O103, O121, O45 and O145 — which are responsible for 75 percent of non-O157 illnesses. She noted the true incidence of non-O157 human illness is difficult to define, due to limited awareness and non-uniform surveillance. Outbreaks worldwide have been associated with varied non-food and food vehicles, including meat.

    While USDA has not yet decided to declare the non-O157 STECs adulterants, Engeljohn outlined the process if the agency does. The agency would:

        * define applicable products from slaughter/dressing and further processing operations
        * issue a Federal Register Notice in the form of an interpretive rule
        * establish an effective date that ensures sufficient time to address seamless implementation for both domestic and imported products
        * issue compliance guidelines
        * issue policy implementation instructions and train FSIS inspection personnel
        * conduct outreach to the regulated industry.

    Well aware of the controversy these and other proposed actions are likely to generate, FSIS Under Secretary Richard Raymond opened the meeting by saying, "You certainly may hear things you don't agree with…Progress won't occur if we're just wanting to avoid discomfort by maintaining the old status quo. The E. coli bug is obviously not satisfied with the status quo and neither should we be."


    More to follow.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    E. coli  |  0 Comments
    Stec
  • Posted: April 9th, 2008 - 3:15pm by

    A Six Flags water park and resort complex in up-state New York known as "Great Escapes", is the focus of a large norovirus outbreak.  Norovirus is transmitted from infected human carriers to food, water, and environmental surfaces. The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recognize noroviruses (and related viral strains) as the leading cause of foodborne illness in the US. The gastrointestinal illness is highly communicable and easily spread by hand to hand contact and even through the air. Outbreaks occur in resorts and other facilities when ill persons contaminate the environment, food and water through vomit and feces. Rapid and effective measures well-known to the public health community are needed to stop transmission. Many of these measures are developed by the US Public Health Service. Cruise lines have experienced many norovirus outbreaks and therefor there is much known about the pathogen and how to address it.

    Untimely Responses to the Problem
    According to the local health department a case of norovirus at the Great Escapes is defined as a person with norovirus symptoms at the resort on or after March 7, 2008. The health department  therefore belives the date of March 7 was the beginning of the outbreak, but did not for some unexplained reason begin an investigation for ten days. It is not known to this writer when the operator of the facility was first aware of that employees and patrons were becoming ill. We are also unaware of how or when the health department was officially notified of the problem. The official coordinated response to this outbreak began on March 17, a full 10 days after the outbreak apparently began. By March 21, there were already 200 cases. The number of reported cases eventually reached at least 435 as news of the incident spread.

    Rapid tests using sophisticated molecular testing platforms are available to provide confirming results of norovirus infection in 24 hours, yet investigators over 1 week into the investigation still didn't have a confirming diagnosis from the state lab.  The slow state lab results were an unnecessary delay, as approved private labs are available.

    Early recognition of this problem is critical. Once it is known that norovirus is in the environment, investigators can implement timely and appropriate sanitation and safety precautions to combat transmission. One example of appropriate response was the closing of the food service. But this only occured after numerous employees of the kitchen reported symptoms of norovirus. The pools, food and lodging facilities are undoubtedly contaminated. Delay in the the implementation of this and other preventive measures at this public, regulated facility likely increased the potential for the exposure of large numbers of unsuspecting people to the pathogen over several days. The licensed operator's delay in recognizing and reporting a large number of ill patrons and staff to authorities, the response of the authorities once notified, and the timeliness and effectiveness of prevention measures taken are critical questions.

    Lawsuit
    Four members of a family sickened by the resort have filed a lawsuit. Key issues that must be scrutinized are the delay between the start of the outbreak and notification of the health authorities, the large number of food service staff ill and whether they worked while ill, the basis for the decision to close the kitchen, and the basis for management's decision to allow the rest of the facility to remain open..

    Unanswered Questions
    A detailed analysis of the cases and their relationships to the food service or other environmental exposures will be key to determining the causes of this large and serious outbreak and whether the operator responded in an effective and timely manner to protect both it's employees and guests.

    Could the large number of cases of illness been reduced if more timely and effective prevention measures were implemented at Great Escapes?

    To read more, select the links below.

    Health Department official statement Norovirus at Great Escapes Water Park
    1st article from the Post Star. March 21st, 200 cases reported
    2nd article from the Post Star, March 16th, 435 cases  reported
    Channel 6 report. Lawsuits filed.

    --
    Mr. Costa is a professor at the Walt Disney World Center for Hospitality and the Culinary Arts at Valencia College in Orlando, Florida and is the founder and owner of the consulting firm Environ Health Associates, Inc.  Mr. Costa is a registered professional sanitarian with 30 years of environmental heath practice in the academic, government and private sectors.

    For our manual on Norovirus Contamination and Control send an email to rcosta1@cfl.rr.com
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Norovirus  |  2 Comments
    Escape, Great, Maple Lodge
  • Posted: April 8th, 2008 - 9:20am by Doug Powell

    People concerned about hospital cleanliness in the U.K. are being urged to challenge health workers on whether they have washed their hands.

    Andrew Pike, chief executive of South East Essex Primary Care Trust, said,

    "We would encourage people using health services to question any healthcare worker, whether in hospital or the community, if they have washed their hands."

    Handwashing public service announcements from the International Food Safety Network are available at:





    http://barfblog.foodsafety.ksu.edu/2008/03/articles/handwashing/handwashing-public-service-announcements/
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Handwashing  |  1 Comment
    Uk
  • Posted: April 8th, 2008 - 8:02am by Ben Chapman

    The April 2008 issue of Journal of Food Protection contains a cool paper on a survey of Salmonella and E. coli at a greenhouse tomato farm in Mexico. During 2003 and 2004 the authors sampled over 1600 product and environmental samples, before, during and after a couple of environmental disturbances: a flood and the entry of wild animals (opossums, mice and sparrows).

    The authors isolated Salmonella Montevideo, Salmonella Newport, and strains of the F serogroup  from tomatoes and go on to state that almost all of the Salmonella Newport strains were isolated from samples collected during or immediately after the flood.

    Analysis by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis revealed that some Salmonella Montevideo isolates from tomatoes, opossums, and mice displayed identical genetic patterns, suggesting that these wild animals represented a potential source of contamination.

    The fun part of paper is that the authors suggest that dirty work shoes were also thought to be an important vehicle for dissemination of Salmonella into (and possibly throughout) the greenhouses (especially after being worn during the flood incident):

    Contaminated worker shoes may be vehicles for contamination with enteric pathogens, from either outside the greenhouses or from one facility to another. The levels of E. coli on personal shoes were higher than those of working  shoes were before the flood. However, there was a higher  level of contamination with Salmonella and E. coli on  working shoes compared with personal shoes after the flood.

    The authors go on to say that sanitary mats intended to reduce pathogen movement may not be all that effective the real-world application:

    Working shoes were provided by management to the workers to wear inside the greenhouse at the suggestion of our research group after finding that personal shoes were positive for E. coli, even after shoes received a disinfection treatment with quaternary salts solution (800 ppm) on a sanitary mat. However, working shoes were not used exclusively inside the greenhouse, but were also worn to go from one facility to another. Shoes have seldom been mentioned as vehicles of contamination in food production areas. This dissemination mechanism of enteric pathogens should be considered as an important control point  during working procedures in greenhouses.

    It's unclear whether this is just a notable finding, or if it represents a real risk in moving pathogens around food production systems, and needs some further investigation.  Probably don't want to use boots to stomp garlic though.

    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    None  |  2 Comments
    Boots, Greenhouse, Tomatoes
  • Posted: April 7th, 2008 - 11:37pm by Doug Powell

    The fans have taken to the streets 90 miles east of Manhattan (Kansas) in Lawrence, celebrating the dramatic come-from-behind-overtime KU victory over Memphis in the U.S. men's college basketball championship tonight.

    People on TV swarming the streets in Lawrence are saying this is the happiest moment of their entire lives.

    Ahem …

    Being Canadian, I don't get all the intra-state rivalry; this KU logo may draw more vigorous complaints than Honduran cantaloupes.

    But I say, good for Kansas. And besides, Kansas State was one of three teams that actually beat KU this season.

    Now, about that hockey arena …
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 7th, 2008 - 10:13pm by Doug Powell

    Careful with that hedgehog, Eugene, especially in New Zealand.

    The Herald on Sunday say police alleged that William Singalargh, 27, picked up the hedgehog and threw it at a 15-year-old boy in the North Island east coast town of Whakatane on February 9.

    Police Senior Sgt. Bruce Jenkins said Monday,

    "It hit the victim in the leg, causing a large, red welt and several puncture marks."

    Police arrested Singalargh shortly after the incident, and charged him with assault with a weapon -- the hedgehog.

    The Herald said the hedgehog was dead when it was collected as evidence, but did not know if it was dead or alive at the time of the alleged attack.

    The Herald reported Singalargh's arrest under the headline "Raise your hands and step away from the hedgehog."
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 6th, 2008 - 7:09am by Doug Powell

    London's Sunday Times ran a little puff piece -- and with spring coming in the Northern Hemisphere there will be many more -- that said food safety problems are primarily caused by eating food already past its shelf life, cross-contamination between raw and cooked foods (often involving poor hygiene) and eating food that was either not cooked or not stored properly.

    Um, fresh fruits are vegetables are the leading vehicles of foodborne illness today.

    Simple precautions include avoiding cooking food that’s about to go off and making sure you dry your hands properly after washing them – far more bacteria are spread from damp hands than dry hands.


    The story cites the U.K. Food Standards Agency as a source for additional information. FSA tells folks,

    "If you are checking a burger, sausage, or a portion of chicken or pork, cut into the middle and check there is no pink meat left. The meat should also be piping hot in the middle. If you're checking a whole chicken or other bird, pierce the thickest part of the leg (between drumstick and thigh) with a clean knife or skewer until the juices run out. The juices shouldn't have any pink or red in them."

    This is bad advice. Color is a lousy indicator of doneness using a tip-sensitive digital thermometer is the only safe way to determine is food has reached a safe temperature.

    And just what is piping hot?

    "To test if food has been properly cooked, check that it is 'piping hot' all the way through. This means that it is hot enough for steam to come out. Cut open the food with a small knife so that you can check that it is piping hot in the middle. Generally, if food is piping hot in the middle, then it will be piping hot all the way through. … Some foods change colour when they are cooked. Looking at colour is especially useful for checking meat."

    I wonder how much money was spent on consultants, and how many salaries sat around a conference table, to conclude that consumers weren't bright enough to understand more accurate messages that would actually protect their well-being.

    Stick it in.


    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 5th, 2008 - 10:14pm by Doug Powell




    The author of La Gringa's Blogicito, whose motto is, Gardening and living in La Ceiba, Honduras; neither is easy for this American woman, writes the FDA Inspectors left Honduras on Friday with no word whatsoever as to the results of the tests at Agrolibano. According to La Prensa, the samples are being tested in the U.S. and the results will be given next week.



    She also says that little has been heard from the Honduran delegation who went to the U.S. last week to demand proof of the tests and a retraction from the FDA either. She does say that she's noticed more balanced reports from various agricultural and commercial experts saying that Honduras needs to vigilantly meet international quality and safety standards, but no admission that salmonella did exist in the melons.

    While searching for the news video, I ran a across a parody of that scene on YouTube. If you speak Spanish, you may get a kick out of the video below, "Mel Melon con Salmonella." Even if you don't, you may find it humorous.






    This is what we advise to safely prepare cantaloupe. And if you want to see just how emotional this issue is, check out the vulgar comments on our youtube video.



    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Salmonella  |  0 Comments
    Cantaloupe, Honduras
  • Posted: April 5th, 2008 - 9:10pm by Doug Powell

    Tellruide, Colorado, has a problem with poop.

    Dog poop.

    A local biologist, Ramona Gaylord, told city council that the impact of waste produced by 100 dogs located within a 20-mile radius of a watershed draining to a small coastal bay would contribute enough bacteria and nutrients to temporarily close it to swimming and shell fishing after two to three days, according to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

    A new form from the Marshal’s Office is due to come into circulation soon. It will enable passersby to document occasions on which they witness owners neglecting their doodie duties. By signing the form the complainant agrees to be called as a witness if a ticket is issued and the matter goes to trial.

    So pick up your poop.

    And if you find some old poop, send it to University of Oregon archeologist Dennis Jenkins.

    Jenkins found 14 feces, or coprolites, in the Paisley caves in south-central Oregon. He reported in Science on Friday that the oldest piece of crap in the collection was 14,300 years old.

    Eske Willerslev, a Danish expert in ancient DNA and one of the authors of the paper, said genetic material found in the ancient poop suggests the earliest known North Americans came from Asia and Siberia, and were the ancestors of modern native peoples

    As they sing on Scrubs, Check the Poo.


    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Wacky and Weird  |  0 Comments
    Poop, Scrubs
  • Posted: April 5th, 2008 - 9:59am by Doug Powell

    Health officials said more than 60 people fell ill after attending a medical convention, with several reporting symptoms as they prepared to leave on flights from Washington.

    Many of the victims came forward Friday, the day after attending the meeting Thursday at the Gaylord National Resort and Convention Center in Oxon Hill, Md.

    Staff members of the Prince George's County health department interviewed resort workers and inspected the center to determine what caused the illness. A private company has already started cleaning.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Norovirus  |  2 Comments
    Gaylord
  • Posted: April 4th, 2008 - 10:58am by

    As many of you reading this blog may know, Rutgers University has sponsored a seminar series on the topic of raw milk.  I am scheduled to present the fourth and final talk in the series on Monday.  Today (April 3, 2008) I attended the third talk in the series: “Raw Milk, A Microbiology Primer” presented by Dr. Mark Gebhart, an MD with Wright State University.

    Dr. Gebhart is a licensed physician and board certified medical specialist practicing in Ohio.  Dr. Gebhart has worked in acute care medicine as a clinician, teacher, and researcher.  Dr. Gebhart has taken special interest in raw milk obtained from grass fed cows and believes many of the gastrointestinal disorders affecting millions of Americans could be cured by consumption of this product.  

    Gebhart spent the first half of his time pointing out in great detail that raw milk contains multiple redundant systems of bioactive components that reduce or eliminate pathogens.  He proceeded to show a series of slides listing more than twenty of these components (e.g. lactoperoxidase, medium chain fatty acids, B-lymphocytes, lysozyme, etc.).

    Gebhart’s focus then shifted to the microbial risks in raw milk.  He cited one study from a reputable journal (Applied and Environmental Microbiology) that showed that levels of the pathogens Campylobacter decline over time in raw milk.  When questioned by one audience member – Dr. Tom Montville – about CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) statistics showing many foodborne disease cases linked to raw milk, Gebhart said the he believed the epidemiological links to raw milk were not conclusively proven.

    Gebhart then shared some statistics from two different sources (American Journal of Public Health and the CDC) that show that there were only 1.9 cases of raw milk food poisoning per 100,000 people, vs. 4.7 cases of pasteurized milk food poisoning per people 100,000.  Gebhart thought that these data made a compelling point in favor of raw milk, until another audience member – Dr. Mukund Karwe – pointed out that many more people consume pasteurized milk than raw milk.  Gebhart then stated that he needed to double check his references.

    Gebhart then shared a number of slides in quick succession on a variety of topics including information on the effect of pasteurization on human breast milk, the safety of milk from cows with access to pasture, and the ability of some pathogens (spore formers like B. cereus and C. botulinum) to survive pasteurization.  Gebhart quickly wrapped up his talk as the debate between different audience members began to drown him out.

    I can’t wait to see how things go on Monday.
    --
    Don Schaffner is an Extension Specialist in Food Science at Rutgers
    University.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Raw Food  |  3 Comments
    Milk, Rutgers
  • Posted: April 4th, 2008 - 9:01am by Doug Powell

    The New Zealand Ministry of Health is working with local and national authorities to determine the cause of an outbreak of Salmonella mbandaka, a strain rarely seen in New Zealand.

    Nationally there have been 28 cases, 10 of which have occurred in the Nelson Marlborough district. A recent death occurred in an elderly woman in Nelson Hospital who had been infected with Salmonella mbandaka.

    The Ministry's Director of Public Health, Dr Mark Jacobs said,

    "… it's worth noting at this stage, no food premises have been implicated and all food samples tested have returned negative results."
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Salmonella  |  0 Comments
    New Zealand
  • Posted: April 3rd, 2008 - 7:40pm by Ben Chapman

    After posting this week's infosheet on a Brazilian soccer club's hep A outbreak possibly linked to dirty water bottles we picked up three more stories on hep A exposures:

    Cincinnati, OH:
    A food handler at a PF Chang's restaurant in West Chester, OH was diagnosed with hepatitis A earlier this week, and today there was a report of the vaccination clinic running out vaccine and sending exposed individuals to an urgent care facility as a back up (resulting in wait times upwards of three hours).

    Boise, ID:

    Nearly 300 people were vaccinated for hepatitis A at Boise's Central District Health this past week.
    The rush came after a health scare at the Red Feather Lounge where an employee confirmed infected with the virus

    New Zealand:

    An orchard worker was found  to have hepatitis A and was  sent home to the Solomon Islands.
    The fruitpicker, who was working at Apollo Pac in Whakatu for the season, was referred to the Hawke's Bay District Health Board's (DHB's) public health unit with the symptoms of Hepatitis A, including nausea and jaundice. The DHB's medical officer of health Caroline McElnay was cited as saying  23 people who had been living in close quarters with the person had also been screened for the disease and given an injection of antibodies for temporary protection.

    Happy hep A day.

    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 3rd, 2008 - 5:12pm by Doug Powell

    Two California girls aged 14 and 15 are in Juvenile Hall facing animal cruelty charges over allegedly microwaving a hamster.

    They also briefly put him a freezer.

    An investigating police officer said the girls have admitting microwaving Bugsy because they were bored.

    "These girls showed no remorse."

    The Press Democrat reports that the hamster, Bugsy, survived, but three of his feet were severely burned. Lake County Animal Control Officer Morgan Hermann said the legs later turned black and the hamster chewed them off, adding,

    “Now (Bugsy) has one leg."

    The incident occurred in December, but it was not reported to Animal Control and police until the students had been released for Spring break.

    Unlike the pic (right) this was not a happy hamster.
    Your rating: None (2 votes)
    Bookmark and Share
    Wacky and Weird  |  16 Comments
    Hamster, Microwave
  • Posted: April 3rd, 2008 - 8:34am by Ben Chapman

    Capitalizing on the massive popularity of soccer, we decided to throw together an infosheet on the reported hepatitis A illnesses linked to a Brazilian club team.  As Doug posted last night, health authorities are linking the outbreak to shared water bottles (they must have been contaminated with some nasty poop).

    You can download the infosheet here.



    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 2nd, 2008 - 6:54pm by Doug Powell

    The South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Control is urging anyone who purchased barbecue at a March 30 fundraiser for the Tega Cay Volunteer Fire Department to throw the food away.

    Firefighters sold approximately 3,000 servings of food and the York County Public Health Department has identified more than 40 people who became ill. Many people bought barbecue in bulk for freezing and later use.

    Tests are under way to identify the cause of the illness.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Food Safety Policy  |  1 Comment
    Bbq, Tega Cay
  • Posted: April 2nd, 2008 - 5:57pm by Doug Powell

    Associated Press is reporting that a hepatitis A outbreak hit the Brazilian soccer team Internacional, sidelining five players who are now banned from any contact with teammates.

    The team said the liver disease probably spread from player to player in the locker room, most likely through shared water bottles.

    Except hepatitis A is not spread by saliva; it's spread by poop. So there was either poop on the water bottles -- possibly from someone's hand -- or poop in the water.

    Or the water bottle theory is wrong.

    Internacional is a former club world champion.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Hepatitis A  |  0 Comments
    Internacional
  • Posted: April 2nd, 2008 - 2:02pm by Doug Powell

    Last week,  Italy's Agriculture Minister, Paolo De Castro, (right) dug into some buffalo mozzarella for the cameras after assuring the European Commission that no mozzarella cheese contaminated with cancer-causing dioxin had been exported.

    On Saturday President Manuel Zelaya of Honduras downed some homegrown cantaloupe for a CNN news crew, proclaiming, "I eat this fruit without any fear. It’s a delicious fruit. Nothing happens to me!”

    Both were continuing a questionable tradition that may actually amplify the concerns of citizens when the safety of certain foods is scrutinized: roll out the politician to consume the food in question.
    The list is long:

    • Canadian Prime Minister Jean Chretien scarfed back a burger after the first case of mad cow disease was discovered in Canada in May 2003;
    • French President Jacques Chirac and future French president Nicolas Sarkozy consumed cooked chicken during the International Agriculture show in Paris in March 2006 to bolster confidence after an outbreak of avain influenza;
    • Norwegian Prime Minister Jens Stoltenberg said in 2006 he often fed salmon to his own children after Russia banned imports of fresh Norwegian salmon because of worries about toxic metals;
    • Pennsylvania Governor Ed Rendell lunched at a Philadelphia Taco Bell in Dec. 2006 after an E. coli O157:H7 outbreak linked to lettuce sickened 71; and,
    • most famously, former U.K. Agriculture Minister John Gummer feeding a hamburger to his four-year-old daughter Cordelia as concerns about the safety of British beef mounted in 1990 (left).

    Do people believe politicians? How about company executives?

    In 2000, 14,700 Japanese were sickened and 180 hospitalized after Snow Brand milk employees failed to properly clean factory pipes for weeks. As reported in The Economist, "At one point during Snow Brand’s latest poisoning scare, its befuddled boss fled a press conference shouting, 'I haven’t slept at all in the past week.'"

    Snow Brand has a bit of a reputation for dramatics.

    "When, almost half a century ago, some 1,900 school children fell ill after drinking Snow Brand’s powdered milk, a dismissive company executive confidently downed a glass of the drink in front of the press to allay fears of contamination. A few hours later, as expected, he was rushed to a bathroom."

    Several years ago, Health Canada proposed to ban the sale of cheeses derived from raw milk, but they failed to provide a compelling case for such a ban. They also ignored the cultural and social factors—the enjoyment—that lead some people to rank specific cheeses like fine wines. Raw milk cheeses can contain the bacterium Listeria which can cause life-threatening illness and lead to miscarriages, but such cases simply had not been seen in Canada (which does not mean such cases did not exist). This left health officials arguing that such cheeses should be banned, even in the absence of Canadian-based scientific evidence to warrant such a ban. The Minister of Health at the time, David Dingwall, was soon in Quebec, scarfing down raw milk cheese for the television cameras.

    People make risk/benefit decisions every time they enter an automobile, smoke a cigarette, have a drink, eat fat or enter into a relationship. Rather than eating up in front of the camera, governments, executives, even local farmers, should provide data to back up their claims of safety.

    Douglas Powell is scientific director of the International Food Safety Network at Kansas State University.
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
  • Posted: April 1st, 2008 - 6:26pm by Doug Powell

    On June 12, 1996, Ontario, Canada's chief medical officer, Dr. Richard Schabas, issued a public health advisory on the presumed link between consumption of California strawberries and an outbreak of diarrheal illness among some 40 people in the Metro Toronto area. The announcement followed a similar statement from the Department of Health and Human Services in Houston, Texas, which was investigating a cluster of 18 cases of cyclospora illness among oil executives.

    Turns out it was Guatemalan raspberries, and no one was happy.

    Last month, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency warned consumers to stay away from Honduran cantaloupes because of a salmonella outbreak that has sickened at least 50 Americans and nine Canadians.

    The president of Honduras is furious. So is the agriculture minister who is demanding millions in reparations, saying the U.S. has not scientifically proven the fruit was infected in Honduras.

    But proof is rare.

    The initial, and subsequent, links between cyclospora and strawberries or raspberries in 1996 was based on epidemiology, a statistical association between consumption of a particular food and the onset of disease. The Toronto outbreak was first identified because some 35 guests attending a May 11, 1996 wedding reception developed the same severe, intestinal illness, seven to 10 days after the wedding, and subsequently tested positive for cyclospora. Based on interviews with those stricken, health authorities in Toronto and Texas concluded that California strawberries were the most likely source. However, attempts to remember exactly what one ate two weeks earlier is an extremely difficult task; and larger foods, like strawberries, are recalled more frequently than smaller foods, like raspberries.

    By July 18, 1996, the CDC declared that raspberries from Guatemala -- which had been sprayed with pesticides mixed with water that could have been contaminated with human sewage containing cyclospora -- were the likely source of the cyclospora outbreak, which ultimately sickened about 1,000 people across North America. Guatemalan health authorities and producers vigorously refuted the charges. The California Strawberry Commission estimated it lost $15 million to $20 million in reduced strawberry sales.

    Once epidemiology identifies a probable link between a food and some dangerous bug, health officials have to decide whether it makes sense to warn the public. In retrospect, the decision seems straightforward, but there are several possibilities that must be weighed at the time.

    Back in 1996, when the Ontario Ministry of Health decided to warn people that eating imported strawberries might be connected to cyclospora infection, two outcomes were possible: if it turned out that strawberries were implicated, the ministry made a smart decision, warning people against something that could hurt them; if strawberries were not implicated, then the ministry made a bad decision with the result that strawberry growers and sellers lost money and people stopped eating something that was good for them.

    If the ministry decided not to warn people, another two outcomes were possible: if strawberries were implicated, then the ministry made a bad decision and people could have acquired a parasitic infection they could have avoided had they been given the information (lawsuits usually follow); if strawberries were definitely not implicated then nothing happens, the industry does not suffer and the ministry does not get in trouble for not telling people.

    These scenarios apply to cantaloupes and salmonella, raw milk and E. coli, and any other combination of food and pathogen.

    It's often not fair. Any hosehead can come along and say, "Hey, I found a mouse in my beer bottle, give me a free case of beer." Or a syringe in some soda. Or I barfed from eating some food. The best producers or manufacturers can do is diligently manage and mitigate risks and be able to prove such diligence in the court of public opinion.

    Douglas Powell is scientific director of the International Food Safety Network at Kansas State University. A video on preparing cantaloupe -- and some nasty comments which highlight the trade and economic issues at stake -- is available here .
    Your rating: None
    Bookmark and Share
    Salmonella  |  0 Comments
    Cantaloupe, Epidemiology