Pediatrician says, irradiate beef, for kids' sake

Posted: January 28th, 2008 - 12:50pm by Doug Powell

Harry Hull, of St. Paul, a pediatrician who served as the state epidemiologist for the Minnesota Health Department from 2000 to '06 and is currently a consultant in infectious disease epidemiology, writes in AgWeek that,

“A year of eating dangerously: 2007 was year of wake-up (re)calls for beef” (Agweek, Jan. 7) should capture the attention of everyone concerned about the future of the beef industry. E. coli kills kids. It's time for industry to accept that the processing methods currently being used for ground beef cannot achieve the level of safety that Americans both expect and deserve.

"Beef producers and processors have made valiant efforts that have reduced, but certainly not eliminated, E. coli from ground beef. Millions of dollars have been spent to 'fix' the problem. Current technologies - steam pasteurization, acid rinses and sprays - can eliminate more than 99 percent of E. coli in ground beef. The percent of contaminated ground beef samples remained steady at 0.17 for three years before going up sharply to 0.20 in 2007. That means that one out of 500 pounds of hamburger contains deadly E. coli and millions of pounds of contaminated hamburger still reach the consumer. This is unacceptable from a public health perspective and would be an embarrassment to any other industry.

"There are no clear answers as to why recalls and illness increased dramatically last year. Some companies made mistakes but others had serious problems despite using used the most advanced technology available. More sophisticated tests and increased testing rates are likely to yield even more recalls in 2008. …

"While ground beef should be thoroughly cooked and properly handled, we know that is not the case in many home kitchens and far too many restaurants. When E. coli contaminated food makes it to the table, children get sick, suffer and die. Industry has a legal responsibility to make sure that products are safe so that our kids remain healthy. The permanent solution to the problem - irradiation - is already in hand and we need to use it.

"Irradiation is a USDA/FDA-approved process and already is being used by several visionary companies, including Schwan's and Omaha Steaks. Many of our spices and an increasing amount of imported produce are irradiated. Pasteurization made milk both nutritious and safe for our children. Irradiation can so the same for ground beef. Let's stop dithering and do what is right for our kids. Ground beef should be routinely irradiated."
Your rating: None
Bookmark and Share
Categories: E. coli
Tags: Beef, Irradiate

Comments

Schlake says:

Pasteurization makes milk less nutritious, so his claim that it made milk nutritious is laughable. I'd also question his notion that it made milk safer. At best, it covers up the disease introduced into the milk supply by CAFO operations, so I don't think we should call that safer either. Irradiation won't do much good to keep the meat safe from consumers unless it is irradiated at the consumers kitchen. Irradiating it far from the consumer still leaves it vulnerable for the whole trip to the consumer, which still leaves the onus of properly cooking the meat on the consumer. The only benefit the consumer will get from irradiated meat is a higher price for the radiation, and depleted and damaged nutrients from the radiation. Oh, wait, those aren't benefits...What we need a safer food industry that produces a less diseased product from the start and a better educated public who knows how to cook the product at the end. Slathering the food supply with snake oil to cover up the problems in production and ignorance in consumption is just pretend food safety.

Posted on January 28th, 2008 - 2:50pm

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.