Is home butchering about economics, safety, or control? Should it be illegal to provide that meat to friends?

Posted: February 20th, 2010 - 2:55pm by Doug Powell

Mark Tijssen, a major in the Canadian Forces, belongs to a group of churchgoers who butcher their own meat to, as they say, ensure its safety.

Apparently, Tijssen's house had been under surveillance for several days last November before officers from the Ministry of Natural Resources and Ottawa police stopped a car leaving the property and confiscated 18 kilograms of pork. Tijssen and a friend had jointly bought a pig and slaughtered it.

Now, Tijssen will appear in court next month to face charges of running an unlicensed slaughterhouse, failing to have an animal inspected both before and after slaughter, and distributing meat. If found guilty, Tijssen could face up to $100,000 in fines.

In the Canadian province of Ontario, it is permissible to butcher an animal if the food is for the person's own family and none of the meat leaves the property where it was butchered. This allows farmers to raise their own food. It is against the law, however, to distribute the meat to anyone else.

Ron Doering, an Ottawa lawyer and former president of the Canadian Food Inspection Agency, told the Ottawa Citizen Ontario's rules on butchering and distribution of meat for personal use go far beyond those of other provinces. Saskatchewan, for example, has no provincial regulation and Newfoundland and Labrador has few regulations, while Quebec and British Columbia more closely resemble Ontario's inspection regime.

Tijssen said he has butchered his own meat for years and cuts food costs by occasionally buying and butchering animals with a group of friends from his church. The members also have little faith in the safety of commercial meat products.

Brent Ross, a spokesman for the Ontario Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs, said the ministry moderates its enforcement of meat handling rules for religious or ethnic reasons, for example, when Muslims slaughter animals for religious reasons.

Tijssen and his friends from Faith Anglican Church say religion plays no part in their butchering practices. They just want economical and safe meat.
 

Your rating: None (1 vote)
Bookmark and Share

Comments

Hannah says:

We only wish we had the skills that this guy's got...we'd love to be able to butcher our own steers or a pig. If we bring our steer to the meat locker to be butchered, it's never guarenteed that we're getting back 'our' meat. A lot of that goes on too. If the guy wasn't selling it, he should not be charged.

Posted on February 21st, 2010 - 9:24am

Anonymous says:

I'm not sure if they exist in Canada, but in the US you can call a licensed butcher who will come to your site and butcher your meat for you. They will arrange for an inspector to be there. Yes it costs a few dollars, but it's way cheaper than the possible $100,000 fine or time in the cooler.

Posted on February 21st, 2010 - 10:02pm

Anonymous says:

you should be able to butcher an animal for your own consumption with a group of people, you have not sold the meat nor distributed it on the underground market. Governmental policy a lot of times isn't about common sense. I'm glad in the US you can butcher your own animal on your own farm. I do know that when you take an animal to be butchered it is likely you don't get that meat back. I had that happen to me, when we arrived to pick up our meat they couldn't find the boxes with our name on it, but where glad to walk in the locker and get out other boxes to give us. Makes you wonder who is really getting your meat. Especially if you do have a license to sell your meat and the person doesn't like it, you can't prove they didn't get the meat from your farm. That is sad and can ruin business.

Posted on February 22nd, 2010 - 1:15pm

John says:

So, you can go out and shoot a bear or a moose, field dress it, (possibly drag it through mud & muck,) process the carcass, and barter it away to friends, but can't process a cow in your own abattoir because it's inherently unsafe? Doesn't that defy logic? I don't see much research on pathogen loads of wild vs. domesticated game, but would be interested to hear what Dr. Powell has to say about it.

Posted on February 25th, 2010 - 9:38am

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.